Stefano’s Pizzeria and Restaurant

Reviews

• Raina H.

  star star star star star 8 June 2026

  Donated six sheet pizzas to our local swim club tonight. Everything was delivered right on time and was hot and fresh. We had many pleased swimmers and parents complementing on quality of the pizza. The owners are wonderful people. Thank you!!!!

• Don T.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 4 June 2026

  Ordered 3 pizzas from here tonight tonight.  I called ahead of time to find out if they had crispy thin crust pizza.  I was told, 'yes'.  Ordered 2 crispy crust pizzas and 1 regular.  When they arrived at my house, the two pizzas that were supposed to be crispy were some of the soggiest, limpest, nastiest looking pizza i've ever seen, and no where near being "thin crust".  I called in and spoke with a manager, they made two more "crispy" crust pizzas and again, when they arrived at my house, they were soggy, thick, nasty crust pizzas.  Both of them went right into the trash.  I'll never order pizza from this place again.  Do yourself a favor, drive to Fastrac and buy a pizza at the damn GAS STATION, because they have better pizza than the PIZZERIA.  Oh yea, we paid almost $80 for 3 small pizzas (two of them inedible and in the garbage) and 20 buffalo wings.

• Tim T.

  star star star star_border star_border 29 May 2026

  A head scratcher. Where to start?
  We dined in and the service was very friendly yet slightly condescending. I know thats a tough statement to make but that's how I felt. We ordered several appetizers to start.  My pal had the Pasta Fagioli soup which he thought later made him ill but initially tasted fine. We split the bruschetta which which tasted good, toast was slightly limp with little crunch. Flavor was good though. I had the calamari which had minimal breading (a good sign) but was slightly rubbery (overcooked) but edible.  We split a pizza which pretty darn good and had leftovers to take home which was nice. Beer was fine, had several Yuengling, taps were clean so beer was good. Took home some Tiramisu which was excellent but at $5 a slice I would of thought you'd get something larger than a small 2 x 2 square.
  This meal was $85. Which I found to be
  Incredibly high for the food portions and quality & we only had 3 beers total between us & we  werent in Syracuse or Rochester.
  Summarizing,
  Place was clean & neat, parking barely adequate, didnt use washroom, service good but didnt seem to focus on what ur saying, condescending. Food slightly above avg, prices reflect restaurant thinking they are a big town operation, but this is Mexico, NY a small town. I would come back but prefer carryout.

• April O.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 22 May 2026

  Very disappointing. We were in town for a district wide conference . Knowing this would be very busy for the area come lunchtime we ordered the previous day and made arrangements for delivery at 12:10. After waiting 10 minutes, we called and were told, "We just got a rush of people, we will leave shortly." Still waiting 30 minutes later, we called again and were told they just left. Another person called and was told, "We will leave shortly. " with our lunch hour just about over, they finally arrived  with missing orders, no napkins, or utensils and with cold food. Needless to say, they have permanently lost my business.

• Val F.

  star star star star star 21 May 2026

  This is our favorite pizza place! Fresh ingredients and the best mozzarella cheese. Usually get delivery. Have never had a mistake on an order. Friendly on the phone and prompt delivery. May be more expensive than gas station pizza but worth the quality! Don't forget to tip your delivery person. Support local businesses!1